MORE RELATED TO THIS STORY
GLOBE EDITORIAL Wanted: Honest talk about moving oil
DWIGHT NEWMAN Provinces have no right to pipeline conditions
GARY MASON On pipelines, politicians are just listening to the people
Video: Alberta Premier Jim Prentice pushes Energy East pipeline in Ontario, Quebec
Video: Enbridges restructuring plan explained
This is surely of national consequence. So it is passing strange that the debate is being led by premiers and even mayors. After all, the Constitution gives Ottawa exclusive jurisdiction in this area, including the Northern Gateway, Kinder Morgan and Energy East pipelines. And the government with the power stands mute.
Yes, the National Energy Board is holding hearings, but that process is getting minimal respect from opponents on three grounds.
First, that it is an alleged rubber stamp. I dont believe that, though. The technical and route environment and aboriginal investigations are thorough.
The second, correct observation is that the process is not considering the supposedly most important matter of all, namely the carbon consequences of extracting oil from what opponents call the tar sands. But the NEB does not have jurisdiction here the matter of carbon emissions is a wriggling monster squarely in the lap of Ottawa, and Prime Minister Stephen Harpers government doesnt want to acknowledge it.
Finally, that for some opponents, the only legitimate answer is no. Minds are made up, and closed. Indeed, if you truly believe that planetary ecological collapse is imminent, it is your duty to lie down in front of the bulldozers.
But most people are neither oil men nor hard enviros. They understand that much of our prosperity and many of our social services are paid for by petroleum production. They also want a sustainable environment. Its a matter of balance.
This majority in the middle cries out for leadership. The leadership of those opposing these projects is strong and skillful. You might think that the oil industry would be leading the pro-pipeline charge, but Big Oil the major U.S. companies quite like the current situation. Canadian oil has no Canadian pipes to get it to the ocean, and so we have to sell it south at a significant discount.
For neutral leadership then, that really leaves governments, academics (who are all over the place) and the news media, which as a whole is more interested in writing about protests than in deep analysis.
Local governments bend to local protests, but this is a national issue. Where is Ottawa? Scared and silent, with an election on its way. Mr. Harper has not spent one ounce of political capital on this file. If things remain that way, my guess is that Gateway and Kinder are toast in our time, and Energy East is a gamble.